Glide Magazine - Music :: Culture :: Life
Search
Subscribe to Email Updates
 
News Feature Articles Music Reviews Columns Free Music Downloads Glide Magazine Giveaways Hidden Track Blog
 

Show Review

Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers / Steve Winwood

 Madison Square Garden, New York, NY 6/17/08

By Shawn Donohue


 
2 Comments

Two legends in the song writing/rocking realm teamed up Tuesday for a torrent of tremendous rock and roll.  Opening the show was Steve Winwood, who as the creative force behind such classic groups as Traffic, Blind Faith and the Spencer Davis Group, has a back catalog of hits that would make most artists blush.  Unfortunately he took his opening hour slot to focus on his new release, 9 Lives which has a new-age-sappy-ending-to-an-80’s-movie feel to it.  Flanked by a drummer, percussionist, guitarist and sax/flutist, Winwood twinkled his electronic keys into easy listening adult contemporary realm way too easily – absolutely boring.  Even when he stepped up and strapped on his axe the rest of the band couldn’t keep up with him on burners “Had To Cry Today” and “Dear Mr. Fantasy.” 

 

 Winwood himself is a virtuoso, smoldering voice, frantic while relaxed guitar work, and extended work outs on the keys were all examples of this, so why was the set so dull?  Just look at who he was playing with, not a wise choice to recruit a band that sounds as if they would be more comfortable playing pool side at the St. George Club in Bermuda.  Then again the airy version of “Higher Love” would probably fit there as well, where is my Pina Colada?!?

 

Oh wait, we are at a ROCK show, and Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers starkly reminded us of that, with the set opening blast of “You Wreck Me” off the criminally-underrated Wildflowers.  From there the hits just flowed, “Last Dance With Mary Jane” waltzed around the arena accompanied by a spectacular light show, “Won’t Back Down” got the juices going before dipping back, as Tom put it, “into the swinging seventies” giving “Even the Losers” permission to bring back memories.  The Heartbreakers have so many hits it is insane, but they reached out for a few rarities including the deep cut “Sweet William,” which meanders in the blues realm before a crashing stop/start breakdown with speed riffing from Mike Campbell – a rare treat. 

 

Also filed in the rarely heard section, was Petty playing The Traveling Wilburys’ “End of the Line,” which sounded fantastic before a call to the stage for show-opener Steve Winwood.  The players jumped from one super group to another with a cover of Blind Faith’s “Can’t Find My Way Home,” and instantly the stakes were raised. With the proper backing, Winwood’s voice and playing soared, evident by the extended jam out of “Gimme Some Lovin’.”  It became clear that Winwood saved his best for The Heartbreakers.  Other highlights of the 20-song show included the muscle pulsing workout that poured from “Saving Grace” and the deep blues of “Honey Bee”. 

 

Petty mentioned early on that “This may be the best room for rock and roll on the planet,” and he was speaking the truth, as The Heartbreakers moved from the heavy metal-ish finish in “Don’t Come Around Here No More” seamlessly into the punk sneer of “Refugee” before closing the whole shebang with the sing along classic of “American Girl.”   Make it last all night.


Setlist

YOU WRECK ME
MARY JANE
I WON'T BACK DOWN
EVEN THE LOSERS
FREE FALLIN¹
CABIN DOWN BELOW
SWEET WILLIAM
END OF THE LINE
CAN¹T FIND MY WAY HOME (w/Steve Winwood)
GIMME SOME LOVIN¹ (w/Steve Winwood)
SAVING GRACE
FACE IN THE CROWD
HONEY BEE
YOU DON¹T KNOW HOW IT FEELS
LEARNING TO FLY
DON'T COME AROUND HERE NO MORE
REFUGEE

E:
RUNNIN' DOWN A DREAM
MYSTIC EYES
AMERICAN GIRL


 

photos by Eric Townsend







  Please login to comment on this article.
. Posted by tommyg914 on 06/19/2008 at 09:24 AM ET
Jpnyc, I have to disagree with you completely. I was at the show and was almost as excited to see Steve Winwood as I was Tom Petty. One the biggest reasons was to see him and his band jam. They jammed alright. They jammed a flat, passionless set into a smaller time slot than I'm sure they are used to. I have to agree with the review about the band. They came across as technical session players with zero soul. If Winwood was up there with nothing but a guitar I would have loved to hear him play all night. But alas, he gave way to a little too much flute and soprano sax. I was waiting for the weather and traffic updates. And not the good kind of Traffic. The song selection was irrelevant as the "hits" were just as boring as anything new. The review actually takes a shot at "Higher Love" to make this point as well. As far as the crowd reaction, I guess you had much better seats than I or have more sensitive hearing. The reaction that I heard was polite applause for a legend's stature. Not an enthused response to the set. Maybe the problem with the band is that they have been playing together for 5 or 6 years. Perhaps they're stale? I can't give a definitive opinion on that as I haven't heard them before Tuesday night. Maybe it was an off night, but more than likely Winwood needs to shake things up and get some new blood on stage that can do him justice. Oh, and by the way, The Heartbreakers were amazing.

. Posted by jpnyc12 on 06/19/2008 at 08:28 AM ET
The show was incredible. I 110% disagree with you on Steve Winwood's set. Great mix of old and new and his new album is up there with his last release, About Time. Mr. Winwood has toured with this band for 5-6 years and they continue to deliver on great jams. You may want to add a disclaimer to your review that your individual tastes are more about playing popular songs and playing them with the original album sound. SW is a rock legend who continues to write great music and seeing the crowds positive reaction to his new songs both at MSG and the next night in NJ back this up.


Latest News
Email Address:
New to Glide